I’m quite confused with the volume meter indicators on DJ mixers. Is it allowed to go over 0db? What is the recommended volume level? Why there are plenty of DJs push it hard above the redline?
Thomas, to answer this question we have to understand what the “red line” and its corresponding numbers are actually means. For instance, does number 10 next to the red LED means overall loudness or what? Such things can be confusing even not among amateurs. Let’s go a little bit deeper into the physical properties of the sound and its perception by human ears.
What is sound
One of the properties of sound, the amplitude, we perceive as loudness. And while most measurements are linear, our ears perceives loudness logarithmically, i.e. by the ratio between two signals. To reflect changes in the volume close to its human perception, we’ve got a unit called decibel (dB). But the decibels are kinda tricky, as basically it’s nothing but a ratio — it only says how loud one sound relatively to another one.
There are two ways to express loudness in decibels: by so-called “dB Gain” and “dB Level”.
“Gain” is a ratio between the sound and its different volume levels. For instance, fader in a typical DAW mixer is an example of dB Gain. If you put it on -6dB, it will make the sound by 6 decibels less than it was originally recorded. The “Trim” knob on top of the each Pioneer’s mixers channel is a Gain too.
“Level” is a ratio between the level of the sound relatively to some reference level. There are several standard reference levels which used to measure the ratio in those particular scales. At this moment I’ll talk only about two of these scales (there are more, but they are not related to the subject). Here they are:
|| Reference level
|Electrical sound waves
Standard operating level for professional audio
|Digital sound waves
Maximum operating level in the digital systems
The physical form of the sound in professional analog equipment comes as an electrical sound wave (voltage), and use a scale known as “dBu”. In this particular scale, +4 dBu is the highest average level that steady audio signal can have, excluding transient peaks.
Audio signal above the reference level (+4 dBu) gradually become more distorted, that’s why momentary peaks can be allowed to exceed. The difference in levels between steady audio signal and the peaks is known as “headroom”. Professional-grade analog equipment can output maximum levels of +26 dBu, which gives us 22 decibels of the headroom.
Setting Sound System Level Controls by Dennis Bohn, Rane Corporation, 1997
Digital sound waves use a scale known as “dBfs”, where “fs” stands for full scale. As mentioned above, 0dBfs is the maximum operating level on this particular scale.
Unlike of analog audio, digital audio doesn’t have such thing as maximum average level, hence why 0 dBfs is the average and the peak levels at the same time. Even average levels can be increased up to 0 dB without distortion, however, anything above instantly becomes distorted as the information get literally lost. That means that steady audio signals can be recorded at a higher average level in digital systems than it could be in analog systems. For instance, 0 dBfs could be equivalent to an analog level of +24 dBu and still sounds clean, while average level at that level in the analog system will be very distorted.
Now comes the most tricky part. Volume meter on DJ mixers reflect directly neither dBu nor dBfs scales, which means 0dB VU (volume unit) on DJ mixer doesn’t necessarily equal to 0dBu output.
When converting between digital and analog systems, these correlation levels must be calibrated, and they can be calibrated differently. Pretty common calibration that used in digital mixers is the following: -20 dBfs = +4 dBu = 0 dB VU. But the correlation (in other words, the headroom) varies from one piece of gear to another. To give an example:
|Calibration: -20 dBfs = +4dBu
||Calibration: -12 dBfs = +4dBu
|0 dBfs = +24 dBu
||0 dBfs = +14 dBu
|-10 dBfs = +10 dBu
||-10 dBfs = +8 dBu
|-20 dBfs = +4 dBu
||-14 dBfs = +4 dBu
|-30 dBfs = -6 dBu
||-20 dBfs = -2 dBu
As you can see, it is really hard to say exact correlation between dBfs and dBu, even the same model can be calibrated a little bit differently. This said, 0dB on the mixer volume meter can mean pretty much anything, unless you know the specs and calibration settings of this particular device.
For instance, Pioneer DJM-900 Nexus mixer has 19 dB of headroom (above zero mark), allowing for that much volume jump before you really hit the clip level. This is a sort of foolproof protection, otherwise, we would experience hard clipping even at the very first yellow LED indicator.
Let’s see what some vendors says about volume control of their products:
Pioneer: “If you experienced distorted sound, adjust the Master Level control so that the master channel level indicator lights at around 0dB at the peak level. ”
Pioneer DJM-900 Nexus Operating Instructions by Pioneer Electronics, 2010
Rane: “Follow the golden rule and keep your level meters out of the red. Think of a level meter as a traffic light. Green means you’re ok to proceed, yellow means caution and red means stop. When level meters hit red, you run the risk of clipping or simply distorting the heck out of the audio. In case you’re wondering, both sound terrible.”
How-to properly set Rane mixer level controls, Rane Knowledge Base
Allen & Heath: “The main meters follow the selected monitor source. The meter reads ‘0’ for an XLR output of +4dBu. The mixer should be operated with these meters averaging around 0dB with loudest peaks no higher than +6dB”.
Allen & Heath Xone DB4 User Guide, Allen & Heath Limited, 2010
So, let’s recap: yes, it is possible to go over 0dB on some DJ mixers without having distortion. However, it is not recommended to go up to the red line as it may cause hard clipping — even vendors recommends to stick around the green zone, with momentary peaks into the yellow, for a reason.
Keep in mind that most venues use compressors or limiters in order to protect their expensive PA systems, so pushing gain all way up will not make the sound louder, but rather make it over distorted.
If you really feel that the overall sound is not loud enough, find the sound guy, ask him to boost volume up on the PA instead. This way you could stay in the safe zone while overall sound will be loud and clean.
A special side note for Ableton users, for those who play live using Ableton like myself. We know that going above 0dB in digital audio literally kills the sound, so it is important to understand that all your efforts for staying in the green zone on DJ mixer will be meaningless if audio that comes from Ableton already has clipping.
If faders on your Ableton mixer are set to 0dB, and you put some audio effect device on top of this channel, like EQ, it is natural that sound will go over zero decibels, hence clipping. To prevent this, I advise to set a maximum value for Ableton faders at -5 or -6dB. Even if you put MIDI-controller fader to its top position, in Ableton it will be still capped at -6dB, and thus you’ll get extra 5-6 dB of “headroom”.
The same applies to any other software, make sure to adjust volume control within the program before check and tweak volume meters on a DJ mixer.
As for your last question Thomas, I guess there is a common misunderstanding among many DJs, so I hope this piece of advice will shed some light.